Need help? Call us on: +44 (0)131 524 9380

 
Close Menu

Mystery Single Malt Whisky

Items 1-51 of 64

Page
per page
Set Descending Direction
A mystery Islay single malt matured for 10 years in a combination of ex-bourbon barrels, ex-sherry quarter casks along with some 'mystery' casks. Bottled by Atom Brands, this is the first in a series ...
IN STOCK
Aerolite Lyndsay
£44.95
Independently bottled single malt from a mysterious Speyside distillery, so mysterious that even the folks at Adelphi weren't told where the original source was when they bought it. It's a cracking se...
Refill Sherry
IN STOCK
Breath of Speyside
£72.95
A single cask of whisky independently bottled from a mysterious Speyside distillery. We have no idea where it is from but we trust the folks at Adelphi so this bottle is sure to be a tasty dram.
Refill Sherry
IN STOCK
Breath of Speyside
£69.95
It's been amazing to see John Crabbie and Co. LTD once again launch itself into the world of Scotch whisky, and this 12 year old release is another great addition to their portfolio. A lightly peated ...
IN STOCK
Crabbie
£32.95
The Crabbie name is synonymous with the whisky history made at the docks of Leith. We're delighted to hear that Crabbies are now building a new distillery in the North of Edinburgh and we can't see wh...
IN STOCK
Crabbie
£30.95
A single malt from an undisclosed distillery bottled by Crabbie's and named after the company's old home in Leith, Edinburgh. This is a single malt designed for mixing and we recommend trying with gin...
IN STOCK
Crabbies
£21.95
A blended malt packed with lots of huge smoky flavour. It's interesting to think which is the Islay distilleries have gone into this corking dram.
IN STOCK
Elements of Islay
£29.95
A mystery malt from independent bottler Murray McDavid which comes from the first distillery to proudly wear the iconic ‘pagoda’ designed by Charles Doig. This has been matured entirely in America...
Bourbon
IN STOCK
Eorna Loin II
£119.95
A cask strength version of this mystery single malt. We always quite like trying to guess which distillery Mystery Malts come from. You should get a bottle and see if you can work it out.
IN STOCK
Finlaggan
£49.95
An Islay single malt whisky. We are big fans of the Ileach whisky. We are constantly trying to guess which distillery it is from.
IN STOCK
Ileach
£4.95
An Islay single malt of excellent quality. Our guys in the shops are big fans of this mystery malt and occasionally we argue which one it actually is. Contrary to rumour, it has always stayed the same...
IN STOCK
Ileach
£41.95
A mystery Islay single malt bottled by the Alistair Walker Whisky Company. This peated whisky was distilled in July 2006 and matured for 12 years in hogshead before it was bottled in June 2019 at a na...
IN STOCK
A mystery Islay malt whisky from That Boutiqu-ey Whisky Company, bottled at 11 years old. The label features a scene from the Islay Distillers Boat Race of 2008..
IN STOCK
Islay #4
£66.95
Heavily Peated Islay Single Malt from a secret distillery.
IN STOCK
Islay Storm
£28.95
This limited release from Peat's Beast is a mystery malt from Islay. At 34 years old, batch strength, and with a Cognac cask finish, this is a unique and complex whisky with a great depth of flavour.
Cognac Finish
IN STOCK
Peats Beast
£299.95
Created from a combination of 2006 and 2007 filled ex-bourbon hogsheads, this edition of Port Askaig is a mystery single malt distilled at one of the distilleries on the north-east coast of Islay. Bri...
Bourbon
IN STOCK
Port Askaig
£65.95
A single malt from Islay bottled by Elixir Distillers. While the distillery is undisclosed, the whisky was all matured for 28 years in refill American oak hogsheads and bottled unchilfiltered.
IN STOCK
Port Askaig
£294.95
This 8 year old release of smoky Islay goodness is the youngest age statement release in the Port Askaig range. We're massive fans of young, smoky whisky so this is a dram which is right up our street...
IN STOCK
Port Askaig
£39.95
Sometimes it can be quite the challenge to figure out where a independently bottled whisky was actually made; but that isn't really the case with Port Askaig. This sweet smoky dram has been bottled at...
IN STOCK
Port Askaig
£46.50
The Isle of Raasay distillery has just opened it doors but if you're curious about how their whisky is going to taste then why not try this handy miniature? The team have worked with another distiller...
Wine Finish
IN STOCK
Oloroso sherry casks have "boldly blasted" this edition of Smokehead - the mystery Islay single malt. With a sweet fruit and rich spice addition to Smokehead's intense peaty character, this limited an...
Sherry Finish
IN STOCK
Smokehead
£67.95
Smokehead has long been the black sheep of the malt whisky world, proudly being different in a traditional market place. This new release is "dialed up to 11" and has been bottled at 58% ABV. A big, p...
IN STOCK
Smokehead
£56.95
Coming from the Isle of Orkney, we'll give you two guesses which distillery this 'mystery' single malt was produced at. Bottled by Signatory at 13 years old, it is a vatting of several hogshead casks.
IN STOCK
Unnamed Orkney
£44.95
A single malt whisky distilled in the Speyside region and bottled by Adelphi. The distillery responsible for the liquid in this limited release is a mystery. If you want to grab a bottle, to try your ...
Adelphi Speyside
£69.95
This cask strength blended malt from Highland distilleries was released by Ian MacLeod. The 10th largest Scotch Whisky Company is not only distilling their whisky (they own Glengoyne, Tamdhu, and soon...
As We Get It
£54.95
'As We Get It' is the cask strength blended malt range from independent bottler Ian MacLeod, the owner of Tamdhu and Glengoyne distilleries, and company responsible (we really hope so!) for reopening ...
As We Get It
£54.95
Another corker from Adelphi, as long as you enjoy a broad and very malty spirit. This is a typical example of the weighty Aultmore spirit, with breadiness, chocolate, spice and citrus. Limited to 480 ...
Sherry
Aultmore
£114.95
Vikings had really strange nicknames. After the "Flatnose" releases the Islay Boys have managed to snare themselves some single malt whisky from their homeland and have named this one "Barelegs", afte...
Barelegs
£39.95
An enigmatic and highly individual whisky from Adelphi, which is a case study in what independent bottling is all about. 33 year old single malt from Benrinnes, which has a mix of dried papaya and man...
Sherry
Benrinnes
£249.95
  Mystery Malt results are here In May 2019, Royal Mile Whiskies and Berry Bros & Rudd collaborated to launch a fun blind tasting competition where drinkers could be in with the chance to w...
RMW Exclusive
Berry Brothers and Rudd
£54.95
The mixture of sweet peat and big rich Sherry characteristics has us quietly confident we've guessed which Orkney distillery Berry Brothers and Rudd have procured this cask from. As there are only two...
Sherry
Berry Brothers and Rudd
£78.95
A mysterious single cask whisky from the Highlands bottled by the fantastic folks at Adelphi, This is a refill sherry cask which produced only 556 bottles.
Refill Sherry
Breath of the Highlands
£76.95
An unnamed single malt from Adelphi, but part of a series praised for its quality.
Bourbon
Breath of the Highlands
£150.00
An unnamed single malt from Adelphi, but Arthur has tried this and has signed it off as 'brilliant'. It has a glorious mix of heather honey and heathery smoke that firmly says 'Orkney'. But as ever, w...
Bourbon
Breath of the Isles
£74.95
A miniature bottle of a single cask whisky from Murray McDavid. This young rich sherry bomb is from an undisclosed Speyside distillery located between Rothes and Keith and even after a short maturatio...
Sherry
Darach Ruadh II
£9.95
A bottling here, from Thompson Bros of Dornoch Distillery, that may be a mystery malt but gives clues to a source distilery with a certain feline connection. Distilled in 2000, this is a 19 year old s...
Distilled In Sutherland
£119.95
Continuing with the catty theme of label art. the Distilled in Sutherland bottlings, from Dornoch's Thompson Bros, have a couple of good clues to suggest where this mystery highland malt comes from. T...
Distilled In Sutherland
£64.95
A single cask whisky distilled in Sutherland in 2000 and matured for 19 years before bottling. The Thompson Bros have some excellent cask selections and while this is a mystery malt, discerning whisky...
Distilled in Sutherland
£109.95
A mysterious malt whisky bottled by Dornoch's Thompson Bros. This whisky was distilled in the Highlands, specifically in Sutherland which narrows down the options quite considerably. Distilled in 2010...
Distilled in Sutherland
£64.95
If you're a fan of Islay whiskies then Finlaggan is still one of the best value for money single malts you can get. This new sherry cask finish takes all the lovely smoke that Finlaggan is known for a...
Sherry Finish
Finlaggan
£48.95
A great value for money smoky dram which is a perfect one to have in the cupboard at all times!
Finlaggan
£34.95
An Islay single malt whisky. We are big fans of the Ileach whisky. We are constantly trying to guess which distillery it is from.
Ileach
Ileach Islay 40% 70cl
£29.95
A mystery Islay distillery bottled by the Creative Whisky Company. We love a good undisclosed Islay bottling; with only 9 distilleries we like to think we can often give a good guess at where the whis...
An unnamed single malt (look, its from Bunnahabhain OK?) matured in sherry casks. Scrumptious.
Sherry
Liddesdale
£94.95
A mysterious single malt from the team at Hunter Laing. It's got a smooth, light peaty kick but is also full of sweet vanilla to keep the balance from being too intense. Matured in a single cask for 1...
Nice 'n Peaty
£49.95
On the slightly peatier side of the Orkney spectrum. This 13 year old whisky was re-racked into Sherry butts for its final two years maturation. Bottled by the increasingly popular North Star.
Sherry Finish
Orkney
£46.95
This is a vintage 2000 single malt distilled on Orkney. We'll give you two guesses which distillery it's from! Selected and bottled from a refill hogshead, producing 343 bottles at cask strength and 1...
Released as part of North Star Spirits Cask Range 007, this is a single cask whisky from an undisclosed distillery on Orkney. With only two malt distilleries in operation, we'll let you try to guess w...
Refill Bourbon
Orkney
£55.95
Although we don't know which distillery this whisky comes from the fact it's from Orkney really narrows it down (there are only two distilleries there!) This single cask from the Creative Whisky Compa...
Sherry
To mark the 10th anniversary of their Port Askaig series, Elixir Distillers have released a limited edition 10 Year Old single malt from undisclosed Islay distillery located close to Port Askaig in no...
Port Askaig
£68.95
Bottled by Elixir Distillers, this is a single cask from their range of mystery Islay malts named after the port town on the north cost of the island. The exact distillery that produced this 34 year o...
Bourbon
Port Askaig
£574.95

Items 1-51 of 64

Page
per page
Set Descending Direction
Buy whisky in Edinburgh
RMW Edinburgh379 High Street Edinburgh EH1 1PW Scotland, United Kingdom
Buy whisky in London
RMW London3 Bloomsbury StreetLondonWC1B 3QE England, United Kingdom
Social Media